Helena once thrived. Tucked away east of the San Antonio River, the unassuming Karnes County town founded in 1852 quickly developed into a crucial South Texas commercial center between San Antonio and Goliad. The former Mexican trading post soon became a highly populated area, gaining a post office, headed by town founder Thomas Ruckman as the postmaster, and a courthouse in 1873. Helena eventually became the county seat for Karnes County, solidifying its legitimacy.


However, Helena developed quite the reputation.
As a stopping point for well-monied travelers and tradesmen with carts filled with gold and goods, Helena attracted bandits looking for a score. A three-day violent clash between American and Mexican ox carts known as the Cart War took place within the vicinity in 1857. Even those earning money honorably would spend it in the Helena saloons and break out in rowdy, often violent, antics. The Helena Guards was founded in 1861 to defend against soldiers, deserters, and outlaws alike during the Civil War.
The townsfolk had to contend with robbers, roughnecks, and racially charged violence on a regular basis, recognizing Helena as “the toughest town on earth” and locally called “Hell” for short. It is even the namesake of the “Helena Duel” in which two opponents are tied together by the left hand and have a knife fight with the right.
So, what happened to this salty spittoon of a Texas town?
William G. Butler was a former Confederate soldier and wealthy cattle driver with a ranch outside of Helena. He was no stranger to fighting off would-be rustlers and bandits. He was also familiar with senseless tragedy. In 1879, Butler’s brother got into a drunken argument with a friend in a Helena saloon and the two took to the streets and shot each other to death. After that, Butler warned his nine children to never go to Helena without him.
In 1884, a gunfight broke out in a saloon. A commonplace occurrence, but this time it would change the fate of a town. Butler’s 20-year-old son Emmett did not listen to his father and wound up in an intoxicated scuffle in Helena, before Sheriff Edgar Leary and his deputy disarmed him. Butler then pulled a revolver out of his coat and SHOT THE SHERIFF. As he tried to flee on horseback, he was shot in the back by one of the many gun-toting bystanders.
Two significant losses on the blood-and-whiskey-soaked streets of Helena in five years were too many for William G. Butler. Furious and grief-stricken, he rode into town waving a Winchester, demanding to know who killed his son. When no one came forward with a name, Butler swore vengeance on the entire town. According to legend, he declared, “This town killed my son. I’ll kill this town.”
The murdered sheriff Leary was replaced by Fate Elder. This raised tensions more as Butler suspected that Elder was the one that shot his son. Things grew worse when Elder appointed his own brother Bud as his deputy. Never mind the fact that Fate and Bud’s sister Mary was married to one of Butler’s sons. The bad blood between the families ran too deep.
The Elder-Butler feud reached a boiling point on September 6, 1886 at a general store in Daileyville in between Helena and Karnes City. The Elder brothers were outside of the store when Butler and his sons, son-in-law, and 10 of his ranch hands showed up with rifles, despite it being illegal to be armed on Election Day. The Elders drew their pistols and a fight ensued.
Sheriff Fate Elder ended up with a bullet in the head. Likely a Butler boy avenging his brother. Bud Elder fired at William G. Butler, wanting to end the feud once and for all, but only grazed his ear before being shot in the head himself. By the end of the Daileyville shoot-out, five men were dead and three injured.
However, William G. Butler wasn’t satisfied. He didn’t just want the Elder brothers. He wanted Helena.
The railroads were developing and Helena as a county seat had been working to get the railroads built near down to ensure a massive economic boost. Butler went to the San Antonio & Aransas Pass office and gave them the right-of-way to build across his ranch…miles away from Helena. The railroads eventually passed through Karnes City, the future county seat. Without the railroad access, Helena collapsed and withered.
Having been bypassed, Helena all but collapsed. As Weldon Hart stated, “[t]he knife-fighters, gunslingers, cattle rustlers, wagon-train toughs, crooked gamblers and all their jolly playmates are long gone from Helena…[t]he wild ones couldn’t take Helena; the railroad did.” Now it remains a ghost town. A dusty relic of rowdy heyday.

The story of William G. Butler was dramatized in an episode of the 1960s Western anthology series “Death Valley Days” available here!




























